COMMON CORE TOWN HALL MEETINGCLEVELAND CHURCH VANDALIZEDJEEP RECALLBATHROOM SPY CAM
WTVC NewsChannel 9 :: News - Top Stories - ABA Rules Lawyers Can Scour Jurors' Social Media Sites
Updated:
Monday, June 23 2014, 01:30 PM EDT
ABA Rules Lawyers Can Scour Jurors' Social Media Sites
Lawyers have been given the green light to scan the social media sites of jurors.

The American Bar Association says it's ethical for lawyers to scour online for publicly available musings of citizens called for jury service — and even jurors in deliberations.

But the ABA does warn lawyers against actively 'following' or 'friending' jurors or otherwise invading their private Internet areas.

Though judges now universally admonish jurors to refrain from discussing trials on social media, the nationwide lawyers group for the first time is addressing how deeply attorneys, their investigators and their consultants can probe for information that might signal leanings of potential jurors, or unearth juror misconduct during trials.

Jurors' online postings have disrupted many legal proceedings over the years, causing mistrials and special hearings over the effects of Facebook musings, tweets and blog writings about their trial experiences. Lawyers and judges have also been wrangling over how far attorneys can go in assembling a jury with help from online research of jurors' social media habits.

A few judges have denied lawyers permission to research social media sites as overly invasive while others have allowed it. One company has gone so far as to develop a software product that promises to create a juror profile through social media posts and monitor jurors during the trial.

The ABA's ethics committee began reviewing the issue about two years ago and concluded in April that looking at Facebook posts, Twitter tweets and other information gathered passively is ethical research.

'It's like any other publicly available information,' said Donald Lundberg, an Indianapolis, Indiana, attorney who helped draft the ABA's opinion as an ethics committee member.

Lundberg said one of the thornier issues for the committee was whether lawyers could view LinkedIn and other social media sites that notify members that they have been searched.

Ultimately, the ABA committee decided a LinkedIn search was ethically sound, which runs counter to an opinion issued by the New York City Bar Association in 2010 that said any notice sent to a potential juror about a search amounts to an unauthorized communication.

'We stay away from LinkedIn and similar sites,' said Leslie Ellis, a Washington D.C. jury consultant. 'We don't want to do anything that would make them uncomfortable to serve.'

Ellis said her firm has been asked on occasion to conduct social media searches of prospective jurors, but only when their names are available days before they arrive at the courthouse. Ellis said prospective juror names generally aren't available until the morning jury selections begins and that time-constraints limit what can be found online.

'Social media searches are time consuming and expensive,' Ellis said. 'What takes so long is confirming that you found the right person.'

At least two state bar organizations have addressed online searches of potential jurors.

The Missouri Supreme Court requires lawyers to research potential jurors' litigation history on a Web site that tracks lawsuits in the state. The Oregon State Bar published an opinion last year that's in line with the ABA guidelines, saying lawyers can access publicly available social media information, but can't actively 'follow' or 'friend' potential jurors.

The California State Bar, the biggest state bar in the country, has not addressed the issue, spokeswoman Laura Ernde said.

Some lawyers are sold on social media searches and have been following the practice for some time.

Last year, New York defense attorney Barry Berke hired a jury consultant firm and instructed it to search social media sites of potential jurors in the insider-trading case of Michael Steinberg. The consultant was looking for anti-Wall Street comments or other signs of possible bias. Prospective jurors thought to be biased were removed from the pool. Still, the former SAC Capital Advisors executive was convicted of insider trading and sentenced to 3 ½ years in prison.

Other lawyers who haven't searched previously now say they will embrace the practice.

'I will be doing it for every trial,' said Khalid Sheikh, a suburban Detroit, Michigan, defense attorney.

Late last month, a jury was deliberating whether Sheikh's client was guilty of first-degree murder when the lawyer's 26-year-old son wondered aloud what the jurors were saying on social media sites.

'I said they shouldn't be saying anything,' Sheikh said, but decided to check anyway. He discovered a juror had made Facebook posts about the case before and after he was empaneled.

After his client was convicted of first-degree murder, Sheikh asked for a new trial, alleging that the posts violated the judge's rule against jurors discussing the case. 'Not cool a young man is dead another young man will be in prison for long time maybe,' the juror allegedly said.

On Monday, the judge denied Sheikh's motion for a new trial, ruling the posting was innocuous. Sheikh plans an appeal.ABA Rules Lawyers Can Scour Jurors' Social Media Sites

Advertise with us!

Related Stories

  • TN/GA Regional News
  • National News
  • International News

NewsChannel9 Top Stories

GMC Mid-Morning Update for Wednesday

Bradley Co Accident Shuts Down Roadway

Georgia Primary Election Runoff Results

Chattanooga's Noise Ordinance: Turn The Volume Up?

Spy Camera Found in Downtown Chattanooga Bathroom

Churches Vandalized, What Tipped Elders Off

Inspector Addresses Parking Garage Safety Concerns

The Political Landscape of Common Core

EPB Releases Findings of Street Light Audit

Chrysler Issues Jeep Recall

Spy Camera Found in Chattanooga Business Bathroom

Neighbors Throw Rocks on Man's Window to Tell Him Apartment is on Fire

Cleveland Gas Station Robbed

Car Plows into Cleveland Business

Child Removed from Home with Meth Lab

Local Group Aims to Help Families with Kids Heading to School

Generous Donation Helps Local Farmers Market

Report: Tennessee Children's Well-Being Improving

Citing Security Concerns, U.S. Airline Companies Scrap All Israel Flights

Catoosa Police Publish Home Invasion Suspect Sketch

Federal Appeals Court Deals Health Care Law Major Blow

GA Voters Head to the Polls in Primary Runoff

Mysterious White Flags Replace American Flags on Brooklyn Bridge

Our Tuesday Facebook Friend of the Day

Prince George Turns 1!

GMC Mid-Morning Update for Tuesday

Third Congressional District Candidates Speak At UTC Forum

Man Sought for Stealing from Children's Miracle Network

Calvin Digs Deeper Into Common Core

Bradley Co. Detectives Need Help Finding Church Thieves

Christan Taylor - A Beacon of Friendship

Busy Intersection Under Investigation After Accident

UPDATE: Biker Community Reacts to Fatal Motorcycle Crash

Chattanooga Coca-Cola Community Expands

Obama Gives Protection to Gay, Transgender Workers

Is Russia Concealing Evidence in Ukraine Plane Shootdown?

Pedestrian Struck and Killed in Chattanooga

Sideroads: Mayfield Farm

Man Adopts a Fine Feathered Friend

Our Monday Facebook Friend of the Day

Middle East Crisis

GMC Mid-Morning Update for Monday

Conserving Water in Chattanooga

Mothers Demanding Stop To Gang-Related Violence

Legendary Actor James Garner Dies

McMinn Sheriff Warns of Scam

Disabled Sports Despite Rain

Chattanooga Woman Using Birthday To Promote Kindness

Restaurants Take Measures To Avoid Over-Serving Customers

Cleveland Crash Survivor Shares His Story

Lawyer Weighs in on Police Order to Destroy Video

McMinn County Murder Suspects in Court

House Fire Training Ends For New Recruits

Obama Protestors Hang Signs at Hamilton Place Overpass

LaFayette Culinary Center Makes Quick Work of Lunch

David's Picks for the Weekend

Kickball Craze Hits Chattanooga

TN Family Invents "Handlebar Helmet"

What We Know, And Don't Know, One Day after Crash of Malaysian Plane

Fire Department Trainees Gather for Customary 'Fiery Photo'

Early Voting Underway in Tennessee, Ending in Georgia

President's Special Address on Plane Shoot-down and Gaza Conflict

FedEx Intends to Fight Drug Shipment Allegations

Campaign Finance Complaint Filed Against Weston Wamp

'Shocking' Jail Problems in Grundy County

Growing Wildfire Empties Washington Town

M17 Shootdown - Calling for an International Investigation

Our Friday Facebook Friend of the Day

Amazing Precision - They Did Try This at Home

GMC Mid-Morning Update for Friday

Snakes Galore - No Rule Against 200 Serpents in House

Rookie Firefighters Staring Down the Beast

Memorial Services Honor The Life Of Cleveland Judge Bill Moss

Settlement Reached for Past Due Liquor Taxes in Hamilton County

Israel & Gaza "Cheat Sheet:" How the Conflict Got to This Point

3 Arrested in McMinn County Murder

2 Women from Athens, Temporarily 'Lost at Sea'

U.S. Officials Believe Malaysian Flight Was Shot Down

Former NTSB Chairman Jim Hall's Take on Malaysian Plane Crash in Ukraine

Israel Launches Ground Offensive into Gaza Strip

Neighbors React to Catoosa County Home Invasion

Chattanooga Fire Department Cadets to Burn Down House Friday

Camp Teaches 7-Year-Olds To Code

VW Plans Welcome Center in Downtown Chattanooga

Dog Hailed as Hero for Alerting Deaf Boy to Fire

2nd Person Dies Following Tuesday's Wreck on Hwy 153

Bank Robbers, Hostage Killed in Hail of Gunfire, Caught on Tape

Couple Calls 911 on Crazed Cat

Georgia’s Unemployment Rate Rises, Still Down from 2013

GMC Mid-Morning Update for Thursday

Our Thursday Facebook Friend of the Day

Hollywood Minute: Beatles Movie, Garth's Comeback and Jillian Bails

International Deaf Tennis in Scenic City

Truck Fire Shuts Down I-75N

Vandals Strike Collegedale Academy

Animal Shelter Accidentally Kills Dalton Dog

Man Ducks Down in Seat to Survive Crash

OOPS! Lizard Takes Live Bathroom Break on This N That

Victim of Machete Attack over Dog Poop Speaks Out

Former Grundy Sheriff's Captain Indicted

Advertise with us!

Newsmax Headlines

Sponsored content

Business News

Asia stocks bolstered by US earnings, home sales

SEOUL, South Korea (AP) -- Asian stock markets posted moderate gains today, bolstered by solid U.S. earnings and home sales.

Consumer Info

   WEST PALM BEACH, FL -- (Marketwired) -- 03/21/14 --
 Companies that pride themselves on being eco-friendly may have conflicted
 ideas between marketing with ad specialties and maintaining their green
 reputation. ...

Entertainment News

CLEANING UP WITH THE KARDASHIANS?

WASHINGTON (AP) -- Call it a case of fighting water pollution with pop culture.

Get This

MARIJUANA AT A MUSEUM

SEATTLE (AP) -- It's one joint that won't go up in smoke.

Science/Tech News

IN THE NEWS: STUB-HUB GETS HIT BY HACKERS

NEW YORK (AP) -- StubHub is the latest online seller to be hit by a security breach.


 

Tonight on WTVC NewsChannel 9

7:00 Wheel of Fortune

7:30 Jeopardy

8:00 The Middle

8:30 The Goldbergs 

9:00 Modern Family

9:30 The Middle 

10:00 Motive

11:00 NewsChannel 9

11:35 Jimmy Kimmel Live

Complete Schedule »


Road Trippin
No Text Zone
Pay It Forward
Storm Track 9 Radar
Storm Track 9 Weather App