JOGGER RAPEDCRASH VICTIM DIESNEW COLD CASE UNITCOMMUNITY CALENDAR: SUBMIT YOUR EVENT
WTVC NewsChannel 9 :: News - Top Stories - DNA Evidence Exonerates Brothers After 30 Years on Death Row
Updated:
Wednesday, September 3 2014, 09:04 AM EDT
DNA Evidence Exonerates Brothers After 30 Years on Death Row
One of North Carolina's longest-serving death-row inmates and his half brother are being freed after three decades in prison after another man's DNA was discovered on a cigarette butt left near the body of a girl the siblings were convicted of killing.

On Tuesday, a judge overturned the convictions of Henry McCollum, 50, and Leon Brown, 46, in the 1983 rape and murder of Sabrina Buie, citing the new evidence that they didn't commit the crime. The ruling is the latest twist in a notorious legal case that began with what defense attorneys said were coerced confessions from two scared teenagers with low IQs. McCollum was 19 at the time and Brown was 15.

Superior Court Judge Douglas Sasser said the new DNA results contradicted the case prosecutors put forward.

He said he was vacating their convictions and ordering their release "based on significant new evidence that they are, in fact, innocent."

Family members of the men gasped and some sobbed as the judge announced his decision to the packed courtroom. Brown smiled and shook a defense lawyer's hand and McCollum looked spent and relieved

"We waited years and years," said James McCollum, Henry McCollum's father. "We kept the faith."

Defense lawyers petitioned for their release after a recent analysis from the butt pointed to another man who lived near the soybean field where Buie's body was found in Robeson County. That man is already serving a life sentence for a similar rape and murder that happened less than a month later.

Because of paperwork, it will likely take until Wednesday for the men to walk free, said Keith Acree, spokesman for the state prison system. They are required to return to the prisons where they have been serving time before they can be processed out.

The men's freedom hinged largely on the local prosecutor's acknowledgement of the strong evidence of their innocence.

"The evidence you heard today in my opinion negates the evidence presented at trial," Johnson Britt, the Robeson County district attorney, said during a closing statement before the judge announced his decision. Britt was not the prosecutor of the men.

Even if the men were granted a new trial, Britt said: "Based upon this new evidence, the state does not have a case to prosecute."

Minutes later, Sasser made his ruling.

The day-long evidence hearing included testimony from Sharon Stellato. The associate director of the North Carolina Innocence Inquiry Commission discussed three interviews she had over the summer with the 74-year-old inmate, who was convicted of assaulting three other women and now suspected of killing Buie. The Associated Press does not generally disclose the names of criminal suspects unless they are charged.

According to Stellato, the inmate said at first he didn't know Buie. But in later interviews, he said the girl would come to his house and buy cigarettes for him.

The man also told them he saw the girl the night she went missing and gave her a coat and hat because it was raining, Stellato said. He told the commission that's why his DNA may have been at the scene. Stellato said weather records show it didn't rain the night Buie went missing or the next day.

Stellato also said the man repeatedly told her McCollum and Brown are innocent.

 Still, he denied involvement in the killing, Stellato said. He said the girl was alive when she left his house and that he didn't see her again. Buie was found in a rural soybean field, naked except for a bra pushed up against her neck. A short distance away, police found two bloody sticks and cigarette butts.

The DNA from the cigarette butts doesn't match Brown or McCollum, and fingerprints taken from a beer can at the scene aren't theirs either, attorneys say. No physical evidence connects them to the crime.

Both were initially given death sentences, which were overturned. At a second trial, McCollum was again sent to death row, while Brown was convicted of rape and sentenced to life.

Lawyers for the two men said the new testing leaves no doubt about their clients' innocence.

"We were very hopeful that it would come out this way. We knew the strength of it," said James Payne, an attorney for Brown.

Ken Rose, a senior staff attorney at the Center for Death Penalty Litigation in Durham, has represented Henry McCollum for 20 years.

"It's terrifying that our justice system allowed two intellectually disabled children to go to prison for a crime they had nothing to do with, and then to suffer there for 30 years," Rose said.

He also credited Britt for making the right choice.

"I give him a tremendous amount of credit. I think a lot of prosecutors would not have done what Mr. Britt did today," he said after the hearing.

The men's cousin, 52-year-old Ted Morrison of Jersey City, New Jersey, walked out of the courthouse and exclaimed: "Free at last! Thank Robeson County they are free at last."

Still, he said the result was bittersweet for his family and for Buie's.

"There are no winners. Because they lost somebody, and we lost two people 30 years."DNA Evidence Exonerates Brothers After 30 Years on Death Row

Advertise with us!

Related Stories

  • TN/GA Regional News
  • National News
  • International News
  • WTVC :: Community - The Good Life

    The Good Life

    Celebrating the events, adventures and activities that represent "The Good Life" in the NewsChannel 9 viewing area.
  • WTVC :: Community - Sideroads

    Sideroads

    Take a ride with Brian Smith to explore the unique people and places to be found along the Sideroads of the NewsChannel 9 viewing area.
  • WTVC :: Community - Road Trippin

    Road Trippin

    Come Road Trippin' with us and see all the great sites in your area!
  • WTVC :: Community - Closings and Delays

    Closings and Delays

    These are the latest School and Business Closings reported to NewsChannel 9. If you see errors or need to add a school or business, call 423-757-7320.
  • WTVC :: Community - This N That

    This N That

    Learn about the latest in community affairs and great events with Brian Smith on This 'N That.
  • WTVC :: Community - Educator of the Week

    Educator of the Week

    Nominate now for Educator Of The Week!
  • WTVC :: Community - Wednesday's Child

    Wednesday's Child



  • WTVC :: Community - Deaf & Hard of Hearing

    Deaf & Hard of Hearing

    Information provided to NewsChannel 9 by members of the Deaf and Hard of Hearing Community.
  • WTVC :: Community - Community Calendar

    Community Calendar



  • WTVC :: Community - Photo Galleries

    Photo Galleries



  • WTVC :: Community - Sponsored Events

    Sponsored Events

    Check Back Often for NewsChannel9 Sponsored Events!

NewsChannel9 Top Stories

One Confirmed Dead After a Terrifying Wreck on Interstate I-24

Men Staying Mum About Sexual Assault

TBI Asks Help Identifying Woman Found Dead 7 Years Ago

Report Says Former Asst. Chiefs Gave 'Improper' Orders, Preventing Relative's Arrest

Tracy Morgan: ‘I Can’t Believe Walmart Is Blaming Me’ for Crash Injuries

Officials Confirm First Ebola Case Diagnosed in US

EPB Streetlight Overbilling Audit Strongly Contradicts City Audit

Harriet Tubman Demolition Brings Jobs to 37406

Saturday Car Crash Victim Dies

Murder Victims Families React to New Cold-Case Unit

District Attorney's Office to Establish Cold Case Unit

New Details about Runner Incident; Police Say Jogger Was Raped

California Becomes First State to Ban Plastic Bags

Michael Phelps Arrested for DUI

Realtor's Body Found, Suspect Pleads Not Guilty

Oklahoma Man Charged with Murder in Beheading

Player Shouldn't Have Been Penalized for Praying After Touchdown, Says NFL

Erlanger East to Expand to Full Service Hospital

Chattanooga Rolling Out Blue Bins for Every Registered Recycler

Da'Rick Rogers Cut from Colts After DUI

GMC's Morning Update for Tuesday

Late Night Shooting on 4th Avenue

Race Organizers, Participants Reflect On IRONMAN Competition

Our Tuesday Facebook Friend of the Day

Chattanooga Police Issue Vague Warning for Runners

Investigation Continues in Allegations of Prisoner Assault

White House Intruder Gets Far Past Front Door

Ty Bramlett - A Good Samaritan to Severe Weather Survivors

Notre Dame/Signal Game Will Be Played At Ringgold

Saboteurs Sought - Oil & Tacks on IRONMAN Tracks

Body Aches and Tired Legs, the Receipt for an IRONMAN Well Done

Suspects Jailed for 'Hate Crime' Assault

Komen Chattanooga Regroups After Storage Unit Fire

Cold Case Murder Suspect Appears in Court

Grundy County Man Charged with Vehicular Homicide in Wife's Death

Local Woman Wins Big in Fantasy Five Drawing

VEC Warns Customers of Phone Scam

Hutcheson Medical Center to Resume Labor and Delivery Services

Toyota Recalls Pickup Trucks

Family-Owned Hixson Business Closes for Good on Tuesday

Tony Stewart Says He's Willing to Talk to Kevin Ward's Family

Fire Forces Rossville Family Out of Home

FAA Orders Review in Chicago Air Traffic Snarl

Bank Robbery Suspects Hams It Up for Mug Shot

White House to Sign Deal to Keep U.S. Troops in Afghanistan Past the End of the Year

Paralysis Link Suspected as Enterovirus Spreads

UPS Worker Trades Stolen $160K Diamond for $20 Worth of Weed

Chattanooga Man Shot on Foust Street

GMC Morning Update for Monday

Helicopter Crash Kills Pilot

Celebrating 100 years!

Our Monday Facebook Friend of the Day

IRONMAN Chattanooga! And the Winner is...

A Family's Special Reason To Race

Tacks and Oil Affect Bikers During IRONMAN

Body Found Floating in Tenn. River During IRONMAN Competition

Oldest Competitor in IRONMAN Chattanooga

Cleveland Family Reunites After 16 Years Apart

Multiple Shootings on TSU Campus

More Teens Escape from the Detention Center in Nashville

"King Fire" Cancels California Ironman, Participants Come to Chattanooga

Prescription Drug Take-Back Day Across Tennessee on Saturday

Fire Damages Storage Building Used to House Race for the Cure Supplies

Collegedale Police Avert Potential Workplace Violence

Family Shares Memories Of Natalia Roberts, Woman Murdered For Her Children

Chattanooga Teen Beaten for Being Gay Tells His Story

5-Year-Old Donates Hair to Locks of Love

Child Struck by Car While Getting on School Bus

Cleveland Man to Serve 10 Years for Child Porn

Hamilton County Officers Accused of 'Excessive Force'

Ford Recalls 850K Cars on Short Circuit Concerns

Bus Driver Saves Choking Student

Woman Beheaded in Oklahoma Murder Case

Athletes Put Final Touches on IRONMAN Preparation

TSA Finds Loaded Gun at Chattanooga Airport, 8th Time in 2014

Made in Our Hometown: Heritage Health Food Makes Snacks for the Healthy Crowd

Best Excuse Ever? Bear Prevents Postal Worker from Completing Appointed Rounds

EPB Tells 30K Phone Customers It is "Critical" to Change PIN

Flights Cancelled Due to Fire at Chicago Airport Facility

Five Most 'Offensive' Books Reported in Your Libraries

FBI Knows Identity of Killer Known as 'Jihadi John'

Meet the Female Pilot Who Led Airstrike on ISIS

Final Home Game an Emotional Night for Derek Jeter

Friday Night Football Preview

What Happens When U.S. Troops Leave Afghanistan?

Facebook Friend of the Day Winner for September

GMC Morning Update for Friday

Parking and Transportation for IRONMAN Downtown

Ringgold Murder Victim's Mother: "I Have Hate In My Heart"

Gay Man Beaten, Chattanooga Police Investigating As Hate Crime

Judge Refuses Bond for Goins in Murder Case

Psychologists Weigh in on Woman Charged in Mother's Murder

Court Grants Stay for Next TN Death Row Inmate Scheduled to Die

Students Wear Orange for Chandler Bolden

Chattanooga Man Sentenced in Federal Court for Jewelry Store Robbery

David's Picks for the Weekend, Plus IRONMAN Road Closures

EPB Responds to Second Lawsuit

How to Cheer for IRONMAN Athletes!

UTC Students Attended Last Weekend's Climate March

Ferguson Police Chief Apologizes to Michael Brown's Family

Advertise with us!

Newsmax Headlines

Sponsored content

Business News

US home prices rise at slowest pace in 20 months

WASHINGTON (AP) -- U.S. home prices in July increased at the slowest pace in 20 months, reflecting sluggish sales and a greater supply of houses for sale.

Consumer Info

   WEST PALM BEACH, FL -- (Marketwired) -- 03/21/14 --
 Companies that pride themselves on being eco-friendly may have conflicted
 ideas between marketing with ad specialties and maintaining their green
 reputation. ...

Entertainment News

TRACY MORGAN-WAL-MART RESPONSE

NEWARK, N.J. (AP) -- Wal-Mart says Tracy Morgan is partially to blame for the injuries he suffered when his limousine bus was slammed into from behind by one of the retailer's tractor-trailers back in June.

Get This

LOCO MOCO RECORD

HONOLULU (AP) -- Mix rice, hamburger, eggs and gravy -- and you get loco moco.

Science/Tech News

IN THE NEWS: NET NEUTRALITY

WASHINGTON (AP) -- Whether you're for it or against it -- you sure can't say that people are apathetic about the subject of Net Neutrality.


 

Tonight on WTVC NewsChannel 9

6:00 NewChannel 9 

6:30 ABC World News Tonight

7:00 Wheel of Fortune


7:30 Jeopardy 

8:00 Selfie
(series premiere)

8:30 Manhattan Love Story
(series premiere)

9:00 Agents of S.H.I.E.D

10:00 Forever

11:00 NewsChannel 9 

11:35 Jimmy Kimmel Live

Complete Schedule »


Road Trippin
No Text Zone
Pay It Forward
Makers Faire
Storm Track 9 Weather App