'WOMAN IN BLACK' REVEALEDTCAP SCORES RELEASEDIMMUNIZATION INFOPOLICE DIVERSITY CONCERNS
WTVC NewsChannel 9 :: News - Top Stories - Medical Panel Suggests Yearly Pelvic Exams Unnecessary For Some Women
Updated:
Monday, June 30 2014, 08:42 PM EDT
Medical Panel Suggests Yearly Pelvic Exams Unnecessary For Some Women
No more dreaded pelvic exam? New guidelines say most healthy women can skip the yearly ritual.

Routine pelvic exams don't benefit women who have no symptoms of disease and who aren't pregnant, and they can cause harm, the American College of Physicians said Monday as it recommended that doctors quit using them as a screening tool.

It's part of a growing movement to evaluate whether many longtime medical practices are done more out of habit than necessity, and the guideline is sure to be controversial.

Scientific evidence "just doesn't support the benefit of having a pelvic exam every year," said guideline coauthor Dr. Linda Humphrey of the Portland Veterans Affairs Medical Center and Oregon Health & Science University.

"There will be women who are relieved, and there are women who really want to go in and talk with their doctor about it and will choose to continue this," she added.

The recommendations aren't binding to doctors — or insurers.

Indeed, a different doctors' group, the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, still recommends yearly pelvic exams, even as it acknowledges a lack of evidence supporting, or refuting, them.

Pelvic exams have long been considered part of a "well-woman visit," and some 62 million were performed in the United States in 2010, the latest available data.

Here's what put the test under the microscope: Pap smears that check for cervical cancer used to be done yearly but now are recommended only every three to five years. So if women weren't going through that test every year, did they still need the pelvic exam that traditionally accompanied it?

During a pelvic exam, a doctor feels for abnormalities in the ovaries, uterus and other pelvic organs. But two years ago, scientists at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reported that the internal exams weren't a good screening tool for ovarian cancer and shouldn't be required before a woman was prescribed birth control pills.

The American College of Physicians, specialists in internal medicine, took a broader look.

Pelvic exams are appropriate for women with symptoms such as vaginal discharge, abnormal bleeding, pain, urinary problems or sexual dysfunction, the ACP said. And women should get their Pap smears on schedule — but a Pap doesn't require the extra step of a manual pelvic exam, it said.

For symptom-free women, years of medical studies show routine pelvic exams aren't useful to screen for ovarian or other gynecologic cancers, they don't reduce deaths, and there are other ways, such as urine tests, to detect such problems as sexually transmitted infections, the doctors' group reported in the journal Annals of Internal Medicine.

Moreover, pelvic exams can cause harm — from unnecessary and expensive extra testing when the exam sparks a false alarm, to the anxiety, embarrassment and discomfort that many women report, especially survivors of sexual abuse, the guidelines said.

No one knows how many women postpone a doctor's visit for fear of a pelvic exam, Humphrey said.

Dr. Ranit Mishori, a family physician and associate professor at Georgetown University School of Medicine, said the new guideline "gets rid of an unnecessary practice" that takes up valuable time that could be put to better use.

"Many women will be happy to hear that, and I think also, frankly, many physicians will be happy to hear it. Many of us have stopped doing them for a long time," said Mishori, who wasn't involved with the recommendations.

Despite its continued recommendation for annual pelvic exams, the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists said in 2012 that patients should decide together with their providers whether to have them.

Sometimes that exam lets the doctor spot, say, problems around the uterus that might lead to questions about incontinence that the supposedly asymptomatic patient was too embarrassed to bring up, said ACOG vice president Dr. Barbara Levy.

"Women have an expectation that they're going to have an exam" if they choose a gynecologist, Levy said.

An editorial published alongside the guidelines Monday cautioned that pelvic exams also look for noncancerous uterine and ovarian growths, and the scientific review didn't address whether that's beneficial.

Still, editorial coauthors Drs. George Sawaya and Vanessa Jacoby of the University of California, San Francisco, said that whether the new guideline changes doctors' practice or not, it could lead to better evaluation of what "has become more of a ritual than an evidence-based practice."

"Clinicians who continue to offer the examination should at least be cognizant of the uncertainty of benefit and the potential to cause harm through a positive test result and the cascade of events that follow," they wrote.Medical Panel Suggests Yearly Pelvic Exams Unnecessary For Some Women

Advertise with us!

Related Stories

  • TN/GA Regional News
  • National News
  • International News
  • WTVC :: Community - The Good Life

    The Good Life

    Celebrating the events, adventures and activities that represent "The Good Life" in the NewsChannel 9 viewing area.
  • WTVC :: Community - Sideroads

    Sideroads

    Take a ride with Brian Smith to explore the unique people and places to be found along the Sideroads of the NewsChannel 9 viewing area.
  • WTVC :: Community - Road Trippin

    Road Trippin

    Come Road Trippin' with us and see all the great sites in your area!
  • WTVC :: Community - Closings and Delays

    Closings and Delays

    These are the latest School and Business Closings reported to NewsChannel 9. If you see errors or need to add a school or business, call 423-757-7320.
  • WTVC :: Community - Educator of the Year

    Educator of the Year

    Vote now on your favorite candidate teacher for the Educator of the Year!
  • WTVC :: Community - Wednesday's Child

    Wednesday's Child



  • WTVC :: Community - Deaf & Hard of Hearing

    Deaf & Hard of Hearing

    Information provided to NewsChannel 9 by members of the Deaf and Hard of Hearing Community.
  • WTVC :: Community - Community Calendar

    Community Calendar



  • WTVC :: Community - Photo Galleries

    Photo Galleries



  • WTVC :: Community - Sponsored Events

    Sponsored Events

    Check Back Often for NewsChannel9 Sponsored Events!

NewsChannel9 Top Stories

Dump Truck Tips Over on Mowbray Mtn.

Hundreds Of Marijuana Plants Found In Grundy County

New Hospital To Aid One Of The Unhealthiest Counties in TN

Mocs First Day of Practice

All on Board For CFC National Championship Game

Chattanooga Police Chief Addresses Department Diversity Concerns

New Clinic Means New Hope for Veterans

Identity of Mysterious "Woman in Black" Revealed

Gas Leak Forces Business Evacuations

Candidates Vie For Hamilton County District 1 Commission Seat

Parents Petition to Preserve Popular Playground

Back to School Means It's Immunization Time

Tennessee's TCAP Scores Released

Marion County Girl Named TN's National American Miss

Woman Testifies She Saw Holly Bobo on Video

GMC Mid-Morning Update for Wednesday

Middle East Update

A Close Call as a Train Comes!

Fugitives on the Run Caught

Our Wednesday Facebook Friend of the Day

Residents Sound Off To Chattanooga City Council On Sound Ordinance

Chattanooga Man Shot in the Hip

Accuser Collapses During Preliminary Hearing for Rape Suspect

Phone Scam Targeting Seniors Spreading to Area Counties

Chattanooga City Council Holds Public Hearing on Noise Ordinance Proposal

McMinn County Sheriff's Office Gets Guns from Military Surplus

Last Airman Aboard Enola Gay Dies in Georgia

House Fire Blamed on Man Using Electric Pump to Transfer Gasoline

3rd Annual GigTank Event Showcases Inventions, Ideas and Innovation

Bipartisan Deal to Reform VA Includes New Clinic in Chattanooga

US & Europe to Impose Tough New Sanctions on Russia

Child's Body Found in Wheel Well of U.S. Military Aircraft

Immigrant Advocates Say They're Puzzled by Governor Haslam's Letter to President Obama

Georgia Mother Charged with Leaving Kids in Hot Car

Overturned Tractor Trailer in McMinn Co

GMC Mid-Morning Update for Tuesday

MUST SEE: Former UT Vol Peyton Manning Dances at Broncos Practice

Ebola Outbreak in West Africa

GMC teams celebrates Drew Bollea's Birthday

Our Tuesday Facebook Friend of the Day

Changes Coming to Bradley SPCA Animal Shelter

CFC Heading To New Jersey For Championship

Chattanooga Man Shot In The Knee

Bradley County Boy Recovering from Dog Attack

Suspect in Hidden Bathroom Cam Investigation Speaks Out

Snow Leopard Dies at Chattanooga Zoo

Peggy Carroll - A Mother to Children in Need

Chattanooga Choo Choo to Undergo an "Extreme Makeover"

1000 Gallons a Minute: Major Flooding on North Shore

First Day In Pads In Tennessee

House Deemed Total Loss After Fire

Local Business Leaders Discuss Climate Change Impact

Hardwick Clothes Celebrates 134 Years in Business in Cleveland

Health Officials Scramble to Contain Ebola Outbreak

Cell Phone Burns Up Girl's Bed

Massive Phone Outage in Cherokee County, NC

HazMat Spill Shuts Down Amnicola

Severe Weather Strikes Across the Country

Our Monday Facebook Friend of the Day

GMC Mid-Morning Update for Monday

Man Dies in Sunday Morning Stabbing

Cleveland Candlelight Vigil for 17-Month-Old Baby

"Rising Star" Contestant with Local Ties

Governor Haslam's Plea to President Obama Over Immigrant Children

Man Drowns in Polk County

Rival Bikers Involved in Shooting in Athens

Roughnecks Memorial for K9 Tanja

Motorcycle Accident in Clevelend

Singing Sensation: Slava Korsak

From Scraps to Art Bikes

More Negative Political Ads Surface In Third Congressional District Race

10-Month-Old Kansas Girl Dies After Being Left In Hot Car

The Price of Freedom: UTC's Veteran Entrepreneur Program

Chattanooga Man Charged with Aggravated Rape of A Child

Common Core Town Hall Prompts Some to Do Their Research

Police Need Help Finding Fraud Suspects

Bessie Smith Cultural Center Picks Independent Auditing Firm

SL Tennessee Adding 1,000 New Jobs

Dalton Starts "Newcomer Academy" for Young Immigrants

Serious Head-On Crash Sends Several to the Hospital

Main Street Meats Creates Unique Cuts By Hand

CFC Ready For National Semifinal

Cleveland Speedway Sold

Who Thinks President Obama Will Be Impeached? The White House

"Ring Cam" Brings New Perspective to Popping the Question

Car Smashes into Chattanooga Gas Station

Motorcycle Accident in Sale Creek

Republican Candidates in TN 3rd District Pick Up Endorsements

Our Monthly Facebook Friend of the Day Winner!

GMC Mid-Morning Update for Friday

Roadwork for Weekend of July 25, 2014

Back to School Breaking Your Checkbook?

Algeria Plane Crashed in Mali, Africa

Speaking Out On The Dangers Of Synthetic Marijuana

Common Core Town Hall Highlights

Graysville Police Chief Reinstated

Common Core Town Hall: Entire Program

Code Violations Being Repaired at Grundy Co. Jail

Quarter Century Anniversary of Cold Case

Dade County Property Owners Facing 44.28% Tax Increase

Advertise with us!

Newsmax Headlines

Sponsored content

Business News

US economy grew at strong 4 percent rate in spring

WASHINGTON (AP) -- After a dismal winter, the U.S. economy sprang back to life in the April-June quarter, growing at a fast 4 percent annual rate on the strength of higher consumer and business spending.

Consumer Info

   WEST PALM BEACH, FL -- (Marketwired) -- 03/21/14 --
 Companies that pride themselves on being eco-friendly may have conflicted
 ideas between marketing with ad specialties and maintaining their green
 reputation. ...

Entertainment News

"SHARKNADO 2: THE SECOND ONE" AIRS TONIGHT

NEW YORK (AP) -- If Ian Ziering (EYE'-uhn ZEER'-ing) didn't need health insurance he might not have made "Sharknado."

Get This

DODGERS-SCULLY

LOS ANGELES (AP) -- Vin Scully isn't ready to hang up his mic.

Science/Tech News

IN THE NEWS: SENATE BILL WOULD END NSA PHONE RECORDS COLLECTION

WASHINGTON (AP) -- Sen.


 

Tonight on WTVC NewsChannel 9

7:00 Wheel of Fortune

7:30 Jeopardy

8:00 The Middle

8:30 The Goldbergs 

9:00 Modern Family

9:30 The Middle 

10:00 Motive

11:00 NewsChannel 9

11:35 Jimmy Kimmel Live

Complete Schedule »


Road Trippin
No Text Zone
Pay It Forward
Storm Track 9 Radar
Storm Track 9 Weather App